Canadian Idol

[Angi]

Hi all, I am from Ontario, Canada so i was very happy when they came out with Canadian Idol so that I could actually vote.

Unlike American Idol fans, I DO NOT vote for who is from Ontario (unless they are the best) but for who is the best.

Last year I voted for Kalan Porter EVERY week so I was sooooooooo happy when he won.

The first year I voted for Billy Klippert (a hometown boy won it) but alas he didn't win

[babybear]

i'm from canada too, i think candians sometimes vote for who is better, not only vote for people who are from their area.

[Angi]

I think so which is sad. American Idol really needs an overhaul especially with this season's controversial win. Simon said it all when Jasmine (very cute, but not better then LaToya) made it as far as she did, everyone in Hawaii has five phones in their homes. I used to live in Kingston, so very proud of Ryan, and he was my second choice, but there was never a week that I didn't vote for Billy.

[babybear]

i was happy that carrie won the last american idol though. i think she was the best and deserved to win.

[Angi]

I liked Carrie I really did and until I realized how GREAT Bo was, she was my top choice, but Bo was the best (it's the rocker in me). PLUS before she won it, there were news paper releases that she had already won, before the final show aired. I read it all on some site before the show aired and I was hoping Bo would win to prove them wrong, and well you know the outcome lol

HEY does anyone agree with me that the wild card group for CI sucked?? I really like Aaron but the judges didn't seem to. And curly haired boy, what the heck was his name???

[Angi]

I find that the CI judges are turning into carbon copies of the AI judges. They overly praise singers that suck just because they like them. I told a friend that I figured they chose that group because the top 8 already are 6 girls 2 guys and they wanted to get two more guys in the top 10 because ALL the girls sucked.

[babybear]

all i know is that i hated that guy that they thought was all rocker. i thought he was like a stage show gone wrong.

[Angi]

which one? there were two rockers. Bo and Constantine.

[Krismas]

I can't stand Josh......I have no idea how he made it through

[babybear]

krismas said:

I can't stand Josh......I have no idea how he made it through

YES JOSH!!! they think he's god's gift to rock but i think he's a character's incorporated type wannabe. he's sooooooooooo bad!!!

[Angi]

Yeah, but I knew Josh would make it because like I said, the judges have become carbon copies of the AI judges. And of course, viewers are letting them control their votes just like AI. The judges went on and on and on about how important it was that Josh make it into the top ten. Why? Not because he's good, I don't even think any of the judges said he was good. I will tell you why. SIX GIRLS TWO BOYS. I know, I'm repeating myself, but how wrong am I?

[babybear]

diamondaurapayge said:

Yeah, but I knew Josh would make it because like I said, the judges have become carbon copies of the AI judges. And of course, viewers are letting them control their votes just like AI. The judges went on and on and on about how important it was that Josh make it into the top ten. Why? Not because he's good, I don't even think any of the judges said he was good. I will tell you why. SIX GIRLS TWO BOYS. I know, I'm repeating myself, but how wrong am I?

i dpn't know what their reasoning his because i think he has no talent at all!! and the looks he gets on his face annoy me to know end.